The International School for Holocaust Studies
In Masechet Brachot, many of the mishnayot focus on the prayers and their laws. During the Holocaust, in the context of the attempt to undermine the life, spirit and dignity of the Jews, the ability of Jews to uphold anything that went beyond the physical was restricted, for example, Jews could no longer set regular times to study Torah. Jews in the ghettos were often forbidden to gather in groups, which restricted any possibility of praying in a minyan – a quorum of ten. In many cases, individuals could not pray at the prescribed times due to the forced labor they were compelled to engage in.
Within the reality of a policy deliberately aimed at denying freedom to the Jews in the ghetto, some managed to assemble for public prayers or find the time to devote to individual prayer, despite the grim conditions. Some even appealed to the rabbis with questions about how to observe the little that they were able. Those who succeeded in observing something of the public or private prayers in that chaotic world, despite the dangers and the supreme effort, gave those actions a deeper meaning, one that we too can draw inspiration from and delve into to gain a deeper understanding.
- A survivor tells about the hiding place prepared for prayer in the Kraków ghetto:
It was not long before we were forced to daven (pray) secretly and in hiding, and davening became very hard work for us, service [lit., “work”] of the heart. . . . In those days we had one redeemer who made our davening easier. He was a young man by the name of Nisan Kreidetz, a student of the great Chofetz Chaim, who managed to find us a safe shelter in which to daven. In one of the dim alleys that twisted and turned near the ghetto, there was a pit that was always covered with a sheet of wood. The sight of the pit was surprising; about 60 rickety wooden steps descended into the ground, that is, six or seven meters underground, to a rocky niche carved out of the bottom of the pit. The niche was about as high as an average-sized man, and the heads of the people who entered brushed its domed roof. The entire niche could hold no more than 15–16 people if they stood crowded together. It was so dim and dark inside that people couldn’t see each other inside the cave. . . This cave then became a place of prayer and supplication. That young man arranged a low wooden shelf inside the niche on which there were always talitot, tefillin, and a few books by his rabbi, the Chofetz Chaim. A glass with oil and a lit wick stood on the shelf, and Nisan would provide the oil and wicks every day.
There is no way to describe in writing how happy those moments were when we were in there.
Heard from a refugee and recorded in the newspaper Kol Yisrael14 Adar, 5704; in Mordechai Eliav, I Believe, Jerusalem, 1990, p. 250).
- “And prayer became a very difficult thing for us” – Why? What are the difficulties in praying in a place like the one described in the testimony?
- Why does the narrator say, “We were happy in those moments we were in it?” What do you think he is referring to?
- In my opinion, the mishna most connected to this testimony is: ______________________________________________________________
- Reuven Ben-Shem (Feldshuh), who was imprisoned in the Warsaw ghetto with his wife and daughter, and who later commanded a unit in the Warsaw Ghetto Uprising, wrote in those days about his feelings during public prayer in the ghetto:
Reuven Feldshuh,Yad Vashem Archive 033/959
- According to the writer, what special strength did public prayer under ghetto conditions provide?
- What is the meaning of the feeling of returning to the “Middle Ages?”
- In my opinion, the mishna most connected to this testimony, is:______________________________________________________________
In the Kovno Ghetto, the Jews who wanted to don their tefillin (phylacteries) and say the morning prayers at the right time encountered a problem. They were forced to work at building an airfield that was about ten kilometers outside the city. The Jews were marched there every morning in military style, accompanied by armed soldiers. Leyb Gorfinkel describes the work as follows:
We did very hard labor [...] very arduous and grueling labor. [...] The Jewish workers had to stand for hours on end in the filth and mud up to their knees. Every shift was twelve hours long.
He also tells of the end of the work day:
For an entire hour, sometimes longer, we would stand on our tired feet and wait for the Germans to collect the workers in a certain place. [...] They hastened the Jews with shouts and blows to run certain sections on the way from the airfield to the ghetto. On more than one occasion, Jews died [...] during the run
(L. Gorfinkel, Jewish Kovno in Its Destruction, Yad Vashem, Jerusalem, 1959)
In this terrible reality, a number of Jews turned to Rav Oshry, who was also imprisoned in the ghetto, with a question about prayer, which the rabbi documented in his book Mimaamakim:
Time and place: 22 Tishrei 5002 (1941), Kovno ghetto
Background: The hard labor in the airfield near Kovno began at four o'clock in the morning, when still dark.
The danger of death hovered over the heads of the forced laborers that came late to work. The work continued into the late hours of the night.
Question: Are the workers permitted to don tefillin, say the morning and Shema prayers while it is still dark outside, before they leave for work?
Response: The rabbi rules that it is permitted to don the tefillin and recite the blessings and Shema prayer while it is still dark because this is a time of emergency, and their lives are in danger. As for the reciting of the Shema prayer, they should try to recite at least one verse later in the day, and if possible more.
(Based on Ephraim Oshry,She'eilos Uteshuvos Mima'amakim [Questions and Responses from the Depths], New York, 1976, Part V, Question 2, p. 25)
Furthermore, in light of these conditions, questions of a more complex nature came up in the context of prayer, as expressed by a cantor named Avraham Yosef, who later perished:
One morning during prayer, Rev Avrohom Yosef, who was leading the congregation in the morning service, reached the blessing, “Who has not made me a slave,” and shouted bitterly to the Master of all Masters, “How can I recite the blessing of a free man? How can a hungry slave, constantly abused and demeaned, praise his Creator by uttering ‘Who has not made me a slave?’”
Every morning as he led the prayers, he let out the same cry! And many of those who joined him in prayer felt the same way. I was then asked for the Torah ruling on this question: Should the blessing be omitted because it seemed to be a travesty- in which case it would be forbidden to recite it- or was it forbidden to alter or skip any part of the prayer text established by our sages?
Response: One of the earliest commentators on the prayers points out that this blessing was not formulated in order to praise G-d for our physical liberty but rather for our spiritual liberty. I therefore ruled that we might not skip or alter this blessing under any circumstances. On the contrary, despite our physical captivity, we were more obligated than ever to recite the blessing to show our enemies that as a people we were spiritually free.
Ephraim Oshry,She'eilos Uteshuvos Mima'amakim [Questions and Responses from the Depths], New York, 1976, Part V, Question 2, p. 25)
- To which mishnayot in tractate Brachot could this question and response relate?
- What is the main point you learned from reading this question and response?
Years after the Holocaust, Rabbi Yehuda Amital of Transylvania, who spent part of his youth in the ghetto and labor camp, related how he felt when faced with the question of “How is it possible to pray?” in light of all the suffering he saw:
My whole concept of prayer comes from there. I saw people, fathers of children, men who had wives – they were all alone, they knew that their families had been taken but did not know where. And so I said to myself: “How is it possible to pray?” We knew from before that the foundation of prayer is gratitude towards God. I said: “What gratitude? People are sitting here without parents, without children.” That’s when I reached the conclusion, which I wrote about later, that one cannot base the worship of God on gratitude, that there is something beyond it. “Though he slay me, yet will I trust in him” (Job 12:15) – that is a higher level. That understanding was strongly impressed upon me then.
(From an interview in Zika,Yad Vashem website, Tevet 2008)
- Which mishna in the masechet before us can we say that the rabbi is upholding with these words?
 In 1939, Warsaw, the capital of Poland, was home to about 375,000 Jews, representing about a third of the city’s population. In September 1939 (Tishrei 5700), the Nazis occupied Warsaw and in November 1940 (Heshvan 5701), the Jews were deported into a ghetto established in the heart of the city. In addition to the Jews of Warsaw, another 100,000 Jews who lived in small towns and villages near Warsaw were also deported into the ghetto. The ghetto was extremely overcrowded, with six to seven people living in a single room. A wall three meters high was built around the ghetto, with barbed wire and shards of broken glass at the top. Due to the overcrowding, the epidemics, the absence of medications and heating fuel and the starvation, the mortality rate in the ghetto was approximately 4,000 each month. In view of the grimly wretched conditions in the ghetto, numerous spiritual and religious figures taught and wrote and underground schools were run. From July 22 to September 12, 1942 (the eve of the ninth of Av to the eve of Rosh Hashanah 5703), most of the ghetto’s inhabitants were deported to the Treblinka death camp. The Warsaw ghetto Uprising began on Passover eve (April 19, 1943), in the context of which part of the remaining inhabitants rose up against the Germans. The Jews that survived the uprising were sent to various concentration and extermination camps and the ghetto area was completely razed by the Nazis.
 The Warsaw Ghetto Uprising, the first local large-scale uprising in Nazi-occupied Europe, and the largest by the Jews, broke out on Passover eve 5703 (April 19, 1943). During the 27 days of fighting in the ghetto, the Germans deployed a large force consisting of thousands of soldiers, armed with tanks. They were faced by 700-750 young Jewish fighters, lacking in any military experience whatsoever, armed almost exclusively with pistols.
 Kovno (Kaunas) is in Lithuania, but in the interwar period (1917-1939; 5677-5699), it was part of Poland, and when World War II broke out in 1939, it was annexed to the Soviet Union. The Germans occupied Kovno on June 24, 1941 (29 Sivan 5701), on the third day of their invasion of the Soviet Union. A few thousand Jews managed to flee into the Soviet Union, and some perished on the way. Before the entry of the Germans, groups of Lithuanians launched bloody pogroms against the Jews of the city, especially in Slobodka. The murders in the city continued after the Germans entered, under their direction. About 10,000 Jews were killed in the first two months of the Nazi occupation.
The 29,760 Jews of Kovno, were imprisoned in the city’s ghetto in August 1941. In October 1941, the Germans began killing the city’s Jews, in the context of which some 12,000 of Kovno’s Jews were murdered on the outskirts of the city, half of them children.
A “council of Elders of the community of the Jewish ghetto of Kovno” was established, and it was responsible for life in the ghetto in general, and particularly for its educational and cultural activities. Welfare institutions, a hospital, school, orchestra, etc. were established in the ghetto. Cultural and religious activities were forbidden, but in accordance with the tradition of the Jews of Kovno, Torah study, educational activities and mutual aid continued in the ghetto. The Kovno ghetto was finally liquidated in July 1944 when the Red Army approached the city. More than 2,000 Jews tried to hide until the liberation in various hiding places that they had built towards the end of the war, but only about 90 succeeded, and the rest were caught and murdered in the places where they hid.
 Rabbi Ephraim Oshry was born in Lithuania and educated in the Ponevezh and Slobodka yeshivot. After World War II broke out and the deportation into the Kovno ghetto, he gave Torah lessons in the Halvayat Hamet kloyz and the Tiferet Bahurim association in the ghetto. Due to the poor health of Rabbi Shapira, Rav Oshi was asked to respond to the halachic questions sent to the rabbi and to express his opinion on them. Rav Oshi recorded the wartime questions on pieces of paper, which he buried in the ground. After the war, Rav Oshry, published the questions and answers in a book called Mimaamakim [Questions and Responses from the Depths]. Rav Oshry did a great deal to rehabilitate the survivors and established a yeshiva in Rome for young survivors that gathered there. Later, he worked to establish yeshivot in Montreal and New York. From 1952 (5702) until his death 52 years later, he served as the rabbi of the Beth Hamedrash Hagadol congregation in New York.